Thanks for all the input!
A word of warning to anyone else reading this thread - I applied online to Grundy because they were cheaper. On their app you have to list ALL liscensed drivers in the home. Of course, being honest, I listed myself as the principal driver, my wife, daughter, and son as liscensed drivers, and listed all our everyday drivers as proof that the Nova wasn't daily transportation. I got a return e-mail today turning me down because "they cannot insure drivers under the age of 25". I called Hagerty and talked with the guy about this and he told me they didn't have a problem with it. SO: I am in the process of filling out their online app now.......