Its an AMD panel are they reputable? im new to doing sheetmetal on a car and I knew for sure that there would be dolly work and spot welding and I dont mind slicing up the panel to get the gaps perfect im just a little afraid of overheating the panel if i add in material i dont want to warp it. My original panel had a gap but only on one side, and i know that was due to damage from a trailer hitch on box truck that backed into my grandfather my father did the straightening of it but it was not perfect the panel should have been changed back then. I took reference measurements on the original and the reproduction and both seem to be pretty much exact. I think this is going to be a challenge but im up for it
Years ago when I was doing metal replacement on my 74 hatchback I bought NOS quarters and an NOS taillight panel and reproduction outer wheel housings from a company I cannot remember the name of.
Even with the NOS quarters the one side I had to section an area out back by the taillight seam as the quarter was let's say 1/4" too long. I planned my cuts, got it fitted and welded in and then was able to dress and finish both sides to where you cannot tell where the work was done.
I am curious as to how well the one is from AMD you have. Not that this area is of concern with your original question, but below is an area on a reproduction taillight panel and how it compares to an NOS one. The reproduction has creased/ripples present while the NOS one is better formed and stamped and is smooth in the transitions.
It's going to be one of those things, how much you want to work on it.
Jim